The Iranian Journal of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Infertility

The Iranian Journal of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Infertility

Comparison of Liquid-based and Conventional Cytology Smears in Fine Needle Aspirates for Diagnosis of Breast Mass

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
Ali Atashabparvar
Seyyede Hakimeh Sajjadi
Assistant Professor, Department of Pathology, Faculty of Medicine, Hormozgan University of Medical Sciences, Bandar Abbas, Iran.
10.22038/ijogi.2024.75057.5867
Abstract
Introduction: Breast cancer is a common malignancy in women and is the second leading cause of cancer-related deaths in the female population after lung cancer, hence its early detection and intervention has a significant effect on changing the clinical course and prognosis of the disease. The present study was performed with aim to compare the cytology results in needle sampling method between two traditional smear techniques and liquid-based cytology to detect palpable breast masses in women.
Methods: The cross-sectional and descriptive study was conducted in 2019-2020 on 65 patients with a palpable breast mass referred to the surgical clinic of Shahid Mohammadi Teaching Hospital. Fine needle aspiration was performed for the patients. One portion of the aspirated material was processed in a non-gynecological ThinPrep liquid setting, while the other was prepared conventionally. The smears were compared in terms of cellularity, epithelial structure, nuclear and cytoplasmic details, and background elements using European Commission breast screening pathology criteria. Both smear methods were also compared with histopathology for confirmation. Data analysis was done using SPSS statistical software (version 23). P<0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Results: The liquid-based cytology method exhibited a cellularity rate of 40% contrasting with 57% in the conventional smear, which had a significant difference (p=0.04). The liquid-based method yielded a clear background, while the conventional method displayed protein content. Cell structure comparison showed no significant difference (p=0.08). Notably, liquid-based cytology excelled in nuclear details, with 55.4% graded as excellent, compared to 49.2% in the conventional smear. High-grade cytoplasmic details were observed in liquid-based cytology, while the conventional smear rated as good.
Conclusion: The liquid-based cytology method has evolved as a new method in the field of cytology and has played an effective role in reducing the limitations of conventional smear.
Keywords
Needle aspiration
Conventional smear method
Liquid-based cytology
Breast mass
Subjects
  1. Pawar PS, Gadkari RU, Swami SY, Joshi AR. Comparative study of manual liquid-based cytology (MLBC) technique and direct smear technique (conventional) on fine-needle cytology/fine-needle aspiration cytology samples. Journal of Cytology/Indian Academy of Cytologists 2014; 31(2):83.
  2. Ban KA, Godellas CV. Epidemiology of breast cancer. Surgical Oncology Clinics 2014; 23(3):409-22.
  3. Nafissi N, Khayamzadeh M, Zeinali Z, Pazooki D, Hosseini M, Akbari ME. Epidemiology and histopathology of breast cancer in Iran versus other Middle Eastern countries. Middle East Journal of Cancer 2018; 9(3):243-51.
  4. Field AS. Breast FNA biopsy cytology: Current problems and the International Academy of Cytology Yokohama standardized reporting system. Cancer cytopathology 2017; 125(4):229-30.
  5. Ogbuanya AU, Anyanwu SN, Iyare EF, Nwigwe CG. The role of fine needle aspiration cytology in triple assessment of patients with malignant breast lumps. Nigerian journal of surgery 2020; 26(1):35-41.
  6. Sustova P, Klijanienko J. Value of combined use of fine‐needle aspiration and core needle biopsy in palpable breast tumors performed by pathologist: institut curie experience. Diagnostic Cytopathology 2020; 48(1):71-7.
  7. Verma P, Sharma R, Sharma N, Gulati A, Parashar A, Kaundal A. Fine-needle aspiration cytology versus core-needle biopsy for breast lesions: a dilemma of superiority between the two. Acta Cytologica 2021; 65(5):411-6.
  8. Schmitt F, Hoda RS. Fine Needle Aspiration Biopsy Cytopathology of the Breast Utilizing Liquid-Based Preparations. The International Academy of Cytology Yokohama System for Reporting Breast Fine Needle Aspiration Biopsy Cytopathology 2020: 159-74.
  9. Ryu HS, Park I, Park SY, Jung YY, Park SH, Shin HC. A pilot study evaluating liquid-based fine needle aspiration cytology of breast lesions: a cytomorphological comparison of SurePath® liquid-based preparations and conventional smears. Acta Cytologica 2013; 57(4):391-9.
  10. Kord S, Mokhtari M, Tahmasebi S. Comparison of liquid-based and conventional cytology in diagnosis of breast mass. Journal of cytology 2019; 36(1):22.
  11. Veerendrasagar RS, Nandish VS. Cytomorphological Spectrum of breast lesions and Diagnostic utility of Fine needle aspiration Cytology. ACHR 2020; 5(1):22-5.
  12. Buch AC, Londhe MM, Patil TV, Rathod H, Dhaliwal S, Gore CR. Comparison of liquid-based cytology and conventional preparations in nongynecological cytology. International Journal of Academic Medicine 2023; 9(3):126-31.
  13. Gerhard R, Schmitt FC. Liquid-based cytology in fine-needle aspiration of breast lesions: a review. Acta cytologica 2014; 58(6):533-42.
  14. Kruajak N, Kranokpiraksa P, Jitpasutham T. Comparing cytological adequacy between conventional smear and liquid-based cytology in ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration of thyroid nodules: A prospective study. Chulalongkorn Medical Journal 2021; 65(3):281-7.
  15. Torous VF, Lopez SH, Xu C, Sweeney BJ, Pitman MB. Performance of rapid on-site evaluation in breast fine-needle aspiration biopsies: identifying areas of diagnostic challenge. Acta Cytologica 2022; 66(1):1-13.
  16. Mygdakos N, Nikolaidou S, Tzilivaki A, Tamiolakis DJ. Liquid Based Preparation (LBP) cytology versus Conventional Cytology (CS) in FNA samples from breast, thyroid, salivary glands and soft tissues. Our experience in Crete (Greece). Rom J Morphol Embryo. 2009; 50(2):245-50.
  17. Effusions MC. Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology with Histological Correlation in Breast Lesions According to Iac Standardized Reporting (Yokohama 2016). Journal of Cytology 2021; 38:S6.
  18. Sharma V, Gupta V, Parmar P, Jain P, Thakran D, Sen R. Comparative analysis of liquid based and conventional cytology smears in fine needle aspirates from breast lesions. Journal of Cytology 2019; 36(2):89.
  19. Mahinderu K, Nandini N, Kishore A, Singh AK. manual liquid based cytology in breast fine needle aspiration–comparison with the conventional smear. IOSR J Dent Med Sci 2016; 1:17-24.
The Iranian Journal of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Infertility
Volume 26, Issue 11
January 2024
Pages 1-12